- Evaluate your peer’s thesis. Is it a strong thesis? Why or why not?
- My peer’s thesis has a very good idea but it is too broad. She should make it more specific.
- Evaluate the evidence presented in the paper to support the thesis. Is the evidence sufficient? Have quotations been adequately explained?
- The evidence is sufficient and I really loved how she quoted and analyzed each point.
- If your peer has a conclusion, please assess the conclusion as well. Does it succinctly summarize the main points of the paper? What “take home” message or idea does it leave a reader with?
- She is missing her conclusion.
